1. John C, August 4, 2010:

   Oh yeah, I’ve been collecting my knives for a reason!

2. nikolasvarma, August 4, 2010:

   you are asking this question under psychology, hence the answer is yes. when defending your self, no doubt that you may need to take this extreme action.
   But i cannot talk about law.

3. justin, August 4, 2010:

   It’s unnatural not to, when it’s you or them, you have to be able to make that choice.

4. Crzypvt, August 4, 2010:

   In most countries and in most american states that is the only way you could kill some one and not go to jail.

   If your question is could i kill in such a situation. The answer to that is in a word yes.

   Simply put. There are things in life worth living for, there are things in life worth dying for, both are worth killing for.

   But yet again that is just me.

   I know alot of people who have a hard time on this subject but i must tell you that in the moment. When you are attacked or when someone attacks your family or invades your home it is human instinct to kill or be killed. If you hesitate on the matter then it will no longer be your problem. you will be dead.

5. iamookae, August 4, 2010:

   I don’t think I could. I know I could hurt someone real bad, but I don’t know if I could kill them. but I have never been in that type of situation, so I really have no idea.

6. jim08200115, August 4, 2010:

   If it were defending my family, the answer is yes. On the other parts of the question there is more that one answer.

7. Sam, August 4, 2010:

   If I was sure the person will harm my kids… yes, without hesitation!

8. neparis2001, August 4, 2010:

   Screw psychology! Try COMMON SENSE!

   I ABSOLUTELY, POSITIVELY GUARANTEE IT!

9. ECREAM, August 4, 2010:

   in a New York minute, but I would not want to kill them I would catch them, beat them to a pulp, break a leg and an arm and then cut them up so they have a reminder of what they did then I would leave them in the street.

10. arya, August 5, 2010:

    as much as u may try clever stunts to avoid killing the person hurting u, finally at the time of attack i feel it wud be ur family u wud be worried about, and then ofcourse urself, i dont think i wud think twice. i’d kill him.

11. toto, August 5, 2010:

    Yes. I think my instincts would take over. If it was to protect myself or my family : definitely…….possessions only . Don’t think so.
    You have had similar answers already..

You must be logged in to post a comment.